Text and Data Mining exception to copyright

Post Hargreaves, the gummint (specifically the Intellectual Property Office) wants to change copyright law to introduce a new exception to permit text and data mining, initially for STM publications (learned journals &c) but possibly for other content also.

But it can't because it is bound by the terms of the 2001 Copyright Directive, which lists allowable exceptions to copyright (which must also be subject to the Berne three-step test, which arguably a TDM exception could never pass).

Whether the gummint is right or wrong, that's a concrete example for you.

They're now lobbying at EU level to re-open the 2001 Directive. Unlikely to succeed for the next couple of years as Barnier is for strong copyright; but with Google on their side don't count them out (Google hates copyright).

Posted By: Old Man on May 3rd 2013 at 09:57:14

Message Thread

What I find puzzling is the huge support for UKIP in farming areas when .. (General Chat) - trustsec, May 3, 07:38:24
- Its not that complicated. A lot of people hate the EU and the fact we have (General Chat) - Jim, May 3, 08:42:12
  - Can you help an interested but ignorant voter out? (General Chat) - Arizona Bay, May 3, 08:52:22
    - Thing is, sovereignty is often illusory in any event (General Chat) - Old Man, May 3, 10:00:22
    - Cor, spot the non-lawyer (badge of pride, I know, I know) (General Chat) - Old Git, May 3, 09:25:31
      - Right. Thank you. But what I'm really after is actual examples (General Chat) - Arizona Bay, May 3, 09:34:27
        
        THEY BANNED BENDY BANANAS!! (General Chat) - Cart Gap Disco, May 3, 10:00:57
        
        It's a dramatic interpretation of what they actually did (General Chat) - King, May 3, 10:29:07
        
        Text and Data Mining exception to copyright (General Chat) - Old Man, May 3, 09:57:14
        
        That sounds like it would be a huge vote winner for UKIP. A really banner to rally behind. (General Chat) - Arizona Bay, May 3, 09:58:38
        
        No absolutely not. But it's a concrete example that I have some profeshnial knowledge of (General Chat) - Old Man, May 3, 10:02:10
        
        AB doesn't actually want any real examples (General Chat) - Old Git, May 3, 10:05:27
        
        No no no, not at all. I just wanted to understand if there was more to that surrender of (General Chat) - Arizona Bay, May 3, 10:17:29
        
        Ok, pols (General Chat) - Old Git, May 3, 10:20:37
        
        "... regaining a bit of that sovereignty *shouldn't* necessarily ..." (n/m) (General Chat) - Arizona Bay, May 3, 10:18:28
        
        my two pennith worth.... (General Chat) - Cheltenham_Canary, May 3, 10:24:15
        
        that's a case in poin though (General Chat) - CWC, May 3, 10:32:29
        
        Its also the physical barrier between the UK and mainland Europe that causes the (General Chat) - Maillot Jaune, May 3, 10:30:14
        
        Farage knew (n/m) (General Chat) - Old Git, May 3, 10:21:13
        
        "What are the things that Farage wants the country to do that at the moment we cannot?" (General Chat) - CWC, May 3, 09:46:16
        
        ^^^This is the correct answer (General Chat) - King, May 3, 10:17:15
        
        well there's the stop members of other EU countries moving here bit (General Chat) - Ralf Scrampton, May 3, 09:45:55
        
        "Wuh! Foreigns!" (n/m) (General Chat) - Arizona Bay, May 3, 09:58:52
        
        That's a very crude take on the immigration debate (General Chat) - Old Git, May 3, 10:03:33
        
        Yes, you're absolutely right, and I apologise for that. (General Chat) - Arizona Bay, May 3, 10:26:20
        
        Basically, people that work harder, more honestly and all that for less money (General Chat) - Maillot Jaune, May 3, 10:25:22
    - here... (General Chat) - Tombs, May 3, 09:21:06
      - The first three cited sources (General Chat) - King, May 3, 10:10:38
        
        Blimey, another non-reader! (General Chat) - Old Git, May 3, 10:14:23
        
        Haha (General Chat) - King, May 3, 10:19:09
      - Mmm. Quite a lot of fairy stories there, really aren't there? (General Chat) - Arizona Bay, May 3, 09:49:00
        
        Ha ha - you didn't actually read it, did you? (General Chat) - Old Git, May 3, 10:12:17
        
        I meant the second link - the UKIP manifesto. Should've made that clear. (n/m) (General Chat) - Arizona Bay, May 3, 10:38:23
- Don't forget the EU farm subsidies (General Chat) - Waddockhunt, May 3, 07:45:26
  - "Dick Seaman" - that must be a made up name (n/m) (General Chat) - CB41, May 3, 08:08:37
    - I bet he has some prize winning bullocks (n/m) (General Chat) - Waddockhunt, May 3, 08:13:58
  - For example (General Chat) - Waddockhunt, May 3, 07:49:50
- even in rural areas I suspect the vast majority of voters aren't farmers (n/m) (General Chat) - mr carra, May 3, 07:41:46
  - Tis true, I based it on the huge number of pro UKIP signs in farm fields (n/m) (General Chat) - trustsec, May 3, 08:06:18

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.