Not very debateable

Sadly Grant only has one season on his CV, and it was distincly crap - so that makes him a crap manager in my book - there's no other track record to judge him with. Redknapp has an outstanding CV, one bad season like you say doesn't make him a bad manager, as he has had lots of very good ones. Context Charles.

I accept that we had no choice in Etuhu and Earnshaw going: my argument related to the use of that money to strenghen the squad - it hasn't happened. Hucks said this is a very poor team a few weeks back - he wasn't wrong was he?

Posted By: Poirot on October 27th 2007 at 17:51:40

Message Thread

Everyone moaning about the board (NCFC) - Capital Canary, Oct 27, 17:06:17
- Utterly delusional (NCFC) - Old Gregg, Oct 27, 17:13:56
  - Is correct (NCFC) - Poirot, Oct 27, 17:17:30
    - yes... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:20:29
      - It's not the board's fault Grant was crap? (NCFC) - Poirot, Oct 27, 17:25:20
        
        your whole post is debatable... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:47:37
        
        Again your shoot your argument, your logic and yourself in the foot (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 17:54:11
        
        so what would you have prefer.... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:57:06
        
        exactly (NCFC) - Charles21, Oct 27, 18:00:57
        
        Sorry how do you know this? (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 18:06:20
        
        yes... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 18:07:57
        
        So you are basically saying we should be thankful we didn't sign him (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 18:10:10
        
        i'm saying we should be greatful we didn't sign him yes... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 18:13:15
        
        Why was the deal being finalised at the last minute? (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 18:16:00
        
        who says it was last minute? (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 18:22:28
        
        Yes... (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 18:30:59
        
        sooo, is it the "boards fault" (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 18:40:06
        
        Doncasters part of the board (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 18:41:22
        
        if we are talking about new ownership... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 18:43:59
        
        Not very debateable (NCFC) - Poirot, Oct 27, 17:51:40
        
        see my post below... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:28:19
        
        Wrong wrong wrong (NCFC) - Poirot, Oct 27, 17:32:16
      - "its not the boards fault that his tenure did not work out... " (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 17:23:48
        
        do you know that not everything in football works out? (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:29:46
        
        So business is predictable is it? Lol... (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 17:36:43
        
        you clearly know nothing about business (NCFC) - Poirot, Oct 27, 17:35:27
        
        exactly (NCFC) - Charles21, Oct 27, 17:34:19
        
        Context Charles - something you're not good at (NCFC) - Poirot, Oct 27, 17:37:55
        
        Fuck off.... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:44:42
        
        Didn't lose money this year (NCFC) - Poirot, Oct 27, 17:48:40
        
        the money that came in on players.. (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:52:46
        
        General delusion of fans - we're all optimists at seasons start (NCFC) - Poirot, Oct 27, 17:57:23
        
        me personally... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 18:01:09
        
        Four new players at least (NCFC) - Poirot, Oct 27, 18:06:37
        
        brellier was god... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 18:10:58
        
        downhill for 2 years you mean? (NCFC) - Charles21, Oct 27, 17:41:36
        
        Downhill since we won promotion (NCFC) - Poirot, Oct 27, 17:46:44
        
        "noone would call for the sacking of the bolton board"? (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:41:21
        
        Well that's unreasonable (NCFC) - Poirot, Oct 27, 17:45:16
        
        Palace board? (n/m) (NCFC) - Charles21, Oct 27, 17:44:05
      - It IS their responsibility (NCFC) - Old Gregg, Oct 27, 17:21:39
        
        huh? (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:26:38
        
        Alan - you are really very stupid. I can't be bothered (n/m) (NCFC) - Old Gregg, Oct 27, 17:27:33
        
        You clearly cant accept the fact... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:31:32
        
        exactly (n/m) (NCFC) - Charles21, Oct 27, 17:34:55
        
        You don't understand the concept of accountability (NCFC) - Old Gregg, Oct 27, 17:34:49
        
        ok lets do it your way... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:42:44
        
        Strawman argument (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 17:48:16
        
        There isn't a team in this league that does not have a debt... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:50:39
        
        No... (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 17:51:28
        
        so there for... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:58:31
        
        It's already been pointed out to you and charles 21 about context... (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 18:02:50
        
        of cause it is, i'm pionting out that the situation... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 18:06:30
        
        I beg to differ (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 18:14:07
        
        sure no problem... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 18:26:02
        
        It may have been worse on paper (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 18:33:48
        
        we went to wolves just a few years back... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 18:35:29
        
        Yes we did (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 18:40:38
        
        or 6 nil sorry (n/m) (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 18:43:37
        
        why does there have to be accountablity (NCFC) - Charles21, Oct 27, 17:39:26
- "we're in a good financial position" (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 17:11:03
  - Answers (NCFC) - Capital Canary, Oct 27, 17:28:27
    - re: answers (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 17:34:30
  - did the bard not just bring in... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:12:49
    - 2 new members who have said they will not be buying Delia's shares... (n/m) (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 17:13:35
      - lol... (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:16:45
        
        Provide evidence for your assertion... (n/m) (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 17:18:00
        
        You know as well as i do there is no "evidence" (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:23:42
        
        The evidence at hand with the current position we are in, is that the turners for the (NCFC) - hubert, Oct 27, 17:25:25
    - board* (n/m) (NCFC) - Alan, Oct 27, 17:13:00
- players all have it too easy (NCFC) - SCC 28, Oct 27, 17:08:12

Reply to Message

In order to add a post to the WotB Message Board you must be a registered WotB user.

If you are not yet registered then please visit the registration page. You should ensure that their browser is setup to accept cookies.