how does it make any difference?

The (new) decision now is do you choose Door 1 or Door 2? (Knowing that Door 3 is a Goat, so that falls out of the equation).

You now have a choice of two doors and you know the car is definitely behind one of those two doors. So you've got a 50:50 chance of picking the right door, whether you stick with Door 1 or switch to Door 2, no?

It then comes down to gaming whether you think the location of the revealed goat has any bearing on the location of the car, and whether asking if you want to change your mind and pick door 2 (instead of asking if you are ghappy to stay with door 1), is a deliberate attempt to sow doubt in your mind because they know you've actually selected the correct door.

Posted By: CWC, Nov 2, 16:25:14