Bellamy offers more to a team I reckon - Earnie is a brilliant out-and-out scorer.

To get 11 goals in 18 starts (and 13 sub appearances) for a team that only managed 36 goals all season is a fantastic achievement, especially when you consider how little Robson seemed to rate him.

Bellamy, of course, had to be sold because Souness couldn't deal with him - situation with WBA is slightly different - Robbo and Earnie don't get on but it's nowhere near as serious. I'd take Earnshaw.

Posted By: Ottosson Foxtrot, Jan 29, 21:32:34